A would-be robber was left seriously injured after attempting to mug a woman who turned out to be trained in self-defense, according to court records and surveillance footage reviewed during the case.
The incident occurred when 21-year-old Lucas Miller allegedly followed Danielle Carter before attempting to snatch her bag. Authorities say Carter immediately fought back, striking Miller repeatedly with her bag before delivering a final punch to his face. Miller collapsed at the scene and later lost consciousness.
Carter left the area unharmed, while bystanders called 911. Miller was transported to a nearby hospital, where doctors reported severe injuries, including fractures to his nasal bridge and eye socket. His left eye was so badly damaged that it ultimately had to be surgically removed.
Miller’s family later filed a civil lawsuit against Carter, arguing that her response was excessive and permanently disabled their son, who they claimed was a boxing coach. The family sought compensation for medical expenses and demanded $1.4 million in damages, stating that Carter had “ruined the life of a 21-year-old.”
Surveillance footage presented in court showed Carter striking Miller with significant force. However, after reviewing all evidence, the judge and jury unanimously ruled that Carter acted in lawful self-defense.
The court dismissed the lawsuit in its entirety, declaring Carter not guilty of any wrongdoing. Legal officials emphasized that individuals have the right to defend themselves when faced with an immediate threat.
Miller is expected to face charges related to the attempted robbery once he regains full contact with authorities.
The case has sparked public debate over the limits of self-defense and whether the court’s ruling was fair.
